To be eligible for this list (as this is more my reading list than an attempt at a master list), fics must conform to the following:
- Contain Lucifer/Michael as the focus or one of the main pairings.
- Contain no Lucifer/Michael/others - these two only, please.
- Contain no straight-out physical noncon, BDSM, humiliation, and the like.
By all means, please rec me some new or missed fanfiction.
Other places you can find Lucifer/Michael:
Lucifer/Michael - An Annotated List
After the Night Comes the Sun by aeon_entwined
Summary: In which bonds are mended, and tragedy strikes.
PG-13 / post-Swan Song, deathfic / Lucifer PoV
Ashira by mithrel
Summary: Lucifer had always been the brightest.
G / drabble / Omniscient PoV
At the End of the World by mithrel
Summary: He never wanted it to be like this.
PG-13 / drabble, deathfic / Lucifer PoV
Before and After mithrel
Summary: Michael remembers.
PG / post-Swan Song / Michael PoV
Bittersweet by aeon_entwined
Summary: In which Lucifer reveals a secret, and Michael’s reaction isn’t what he expects.
R / smut, angst / Michael PoV
But to Bring a Sword by sarkasticfics
Summary: Two forces meet at the edge of the world.
NC-17 / wincest, smut, drama / Michael PoV
Ceasefire by mithrel
Summary: Michael and Lucifer reconcile.
PG / post-Swan Song / Lucifer PoV
The Dark Before and After by guardiancastiel
Summary: Events after 5x22 between Michael and Lucifer, and events before time was a concept.
PG-13 / drama, angst / Michael PoV
First, Do No Harm by holydread
Summary: Wherein Lucifer faces demon blood detox - human style.
PG-13 / hurt/comfort / Michael PoV
Given Eternity, I'd Rather Fall by tigriswolf
Summary: Dreams of burning wings.
PG / romance / Michael PoV
Heat Lightning by holydread
Summary: The memory of the final battle haunts them both.
NC-17 / smut, angst / Michael PoV
Imagine a Figure Eight by fourfreedoms
Summary: In order to stop Lucifer and the apocalypse, Michael thrusts them both outside time.
R / humour, slight wincest / Lucifer PoV
Infernal World by holydread
Summary: Wherein Michael is at the mercy of a monster.
PG / post-Swan Song / Michael PoV
Intemporaliter Vestri by aeon_entwined
Summary: In which bonds deeper than blood are re-forged.
PG-13 / post-Swan Song / Lucifer PoV
It Wasn't the First Time by dark_princess17
Summary: It wasn't the first time he'd said those words to you.
PG / drabble / Lucifer PoV (2nd)
It Would Always Be Wrong by dark_princess17
Summary: It didn't matter how "right" things may have felt ... for a time.
PG / angst / Michael PoV
Life is the Pits by bladeachilles and jones6
Summary: In which murder is attempted, archangels work through their issues using hospital dramas, and Michael takes care of his skin.
PG / crack, humour / Shifting PoV
Michael (or Heaven's a Lie) by angelshandprint
Summary: Michael's unconscious trip through the land of memories and dreams.
R / introspective / Michael PoV
My Brother's Keeper by highermagic
Summary: Dean and Michael just want their brothers to come home.
R / wincest, angst / Michael PoV
My Brother, My Love by xephwrites
Summary: Sam and Dean are so much more like Michael and Lucifer than they realized.
PG-13 / wincest, angst / Michael PoV
Nature vs Nurture by tigriswolf
Summary: After all of the long years, he's still too proud to ask for forgiveness.
PG / violence / Omniscient PoV
Oh Brother Where Art Thou? by bellajayd
Summary: The plan is everything, because I will not spend all of eternity without my love. I refuse. I am the Morning Star’s brother and Heaven should never have forgotten that.
R / Dean/Cas, romance, drama / Michael PoV
Over and Over by character_bleed
Summary: Over and over, over and over I Fall for you.
R / dark, violence, smut / Lucifer PoV
Patience is a Virtue by emerald_embers
Summary: They're both trapped forever; they might as well make the most of it, if they can.
NC-17 / violence, smut / Lucifer PoV
The Rest is Missing by kijikun
Summary: You can't fix things anymore.
PG-13 / angst / Lucifer PoV
Silence for Dummies by secondplatypus
Summary: Lucifer finally figures out a way to shut his big brother up.
R / crack, humour / Lucifer PoV
Too High a Price? by dark_princess17
Summary: You believe that it is worth everything and you will pay that price ... but it is really? Or is "everything" too high of a price to pay?
PG-13 / angst / Lucifer PoV (2nd)
Whisper in the Dark by jeannedecarnin
Summary: Welcome to the end of the world.
NC-17 / dark, smut / Lucifer Pov